Cancer Confusion: Are Mammograms Necessary?

Cancer Confusion: Are Mammograms Necessary?

So the debate over the benefit of screening mammography has been ongoing the past several years and has recently heated up due to a study in the Journal of the American Medical Association that was discussed earlier this week in the New York Times. There have been several recent papers like this one stating that some women (1 in 3–a disputed figure) are overdiagnosed by screening mammograms, and some women are in age groups that do not necessarily benefit from screening of their breasts by mammography (the under 50 and over 70 year-olds). Click above for the Youtube video where Alisyn Camerota of Fox and Friends top rated morning show interviews me on this hot topic. I am reluctant to fully accept a change in the screening mammography recommendations of the American Cancer Society at the present moment for the following reasons:

Breast cancer is a lethal disease that occurs in 1 in 7 women. Deaths from breast cancer have fallen to the lowest levels in 50 years, although the overall # of cases has risen due to early screening and detection. When dealing with cancer, you want to avoid people dying unnecessarily by performing screening tests (in this case, mammography). When patients are faced with a diagnosis from a screening test, they are usually going to opt for treatment. Screening saves over 1000 lives per year. Unfortunately, we cannot predict which cancer will go on to develop into a more dangerous and life-threatening cancer and which won’t. It would be very difficult to say “no, let’s go ahead and just watch that” to a woman with a suspicious lesion on her mammogram.

Many researchers and clinicians still think the benefits of screening mammography outweigh the risks. Doubts raised by the authors of these studies that question mammography in 40-50 year olds and over 70 year olds are still too weak shake many experts’ belief in breast screening. Women cannot take the risk of not being diagnosed and treated and screening is a major way for this to happen. One of the troubles with any screening program is that it turns up people whom the disease would run a benign course…you overdiagnose in some instances and therefore overtreat that person. As it is not possible to distinguish between lethal and “harmless” cancers on an imaging study, all detected cancers are treated. Overdiagnosis and overtreatment are therefore inevitable. As the author of the JAMA study said, more studies will be needed to distinguish between slow growing and very aggressive tumors. But for now, if a woman wants to reduce her odds of dying of breast cancer (by at least 24%), then the current screening regimen should be followed. Besides just a cookie cutter approach to every female going to get an x-ray of the breast, public education campaigns should also be reinforced to teach women how to assess their own risk including not having kids till late in life, dense breast tissue, family history of breast cancer, genetic testing for BRCA gene, aging, taking female hormones for menopause symptoms, etc. This should be addressed on a case by case basis between an individual and her health care provider, and women should be made aware of the risks of possible overtreatment and overdiagnosis, radiation exposure, and limitations of screening mammography in picking up some quickly growing breast cancers that can be deadly. MRI can also be useful in picking up some lesions and later stage cancers that mammography may miss.

I also have a personal interest in this topic as my mom’s life was saved by a screening mammogram. One year she had a normal study and the next year she had a breast cancer that was picked up on the yearly mammogram. It had already spread microscopically to her lymph node, meaning it was an aggressive tumor and if she had just skipped a year or blown off that year’s mammogram, she would have missed picking up the cancer and it would have likely spread beyond the breast and been metastatic by then which is often lethal. It should be noted she was in her late 60’s at the time of her diagnosis, which means she falls in the 50-70 year old category that studies have demonstrated a clear benefit of yearly screening mammography. So it’s hard to imagine backing down on mammograms in the absence of more sophisticated screening measures when you have a personal story like this one that make you so thankful for screening studies; many people besides myself have these stories since so many women are affected by breast cancer.

JOIN THE MEDSPA AUSTIN VIP AND RECEIVE $75 OFF ANY SERVICE

Plus, for each visit, earn rewards like:

(1) EmSculpt or EmSculpt NEO Treatment

10-Units of Botox

VIP Birthday Gift – 15% Off any skincare product and much more!

Request a Consultation

  • This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Follow Us on Instagram

Reveal your radiant glow with our MicroLaser Peel!
Say goodbye to dull skin and hello to a smoother, more 
youthful complexion. 😍

$350 Full Face Single Treatment until April 30, 2024

Book your treatment today and shine brighter than ever before! ✨
☎️Phone: (512)328-4100 ext. 2 Westlake Hills;
(512)640-8111 Northwest Hills
📆Book online: https://bit.ly/BookMedSpaAustin
📧Email: info@drjenniferwalden.com
🌎Website: TheMedSpaAustin.com 
🎟️Memberships: https://bit.ly/medspamember
🛍 Shop: https://shop.drjenniferwalden.com/
⭐️Join our VIP App: https://drwalden.repeatmd.com/
🍒 Apply For Cherry: https://pay.withcherry.com/the-medspa-at-westlake-hills-by-dr-jennifer-walden
💳 Finance Today with Patient Fi https://app.patientfi.com/v2/drjenniferwalden/enterprise

#MicroLaserPeel #SkinRejuvenation #antiaging #finelines #wrinkles #sciton #scitonjoule #scitonlaser #glowup #atxmedspa #medspaspecials #themedspaaustin #drjenniferwalden
✨Refresh, Renew, Reveal with our Hydrafacial Treatment! ✨ 

Say goodbye to dull skin and hello to glowing results! Book your session today and experience the ultimate skincare indulgence. 

$125 Hydrafacial (reg. $175) until April 30, 2024 *only offered at our Westlake Hills office

☎️Phone: (512)328-4100 ext. 2 Westlake Hills;
(512)640-8111 Northwest Hills
📆Book online: https://bit.ly/BookMedSpaAustin
📧Email: info@drjenniferwalden.com
🌎Website: TheMedSpaAustin.com 
🎟️Memberships: https://bit.ly/medspamember
🛍 Shop: https://shop.drjenniferwalden.com/
⭐️Join our VIP App: https://drwalden.repeatmd.com/
🍒 Apply For Cherry: https://pay.withcherry.com/the-medspa-at-westlake-hills-by-dr-jennifer-walden
💳 Finance Today with Patient Fi https://app.patientfi.com/v2/drjenniferwalden/enterprise

#Hydrafacial #GlowingSkin #SkincareRoutine
#atxmedspa #antiaging #skinglowup #clearskin #themedspaaustin #drjenniferwalden
It’s time to clarify your pores with @SkinMedica Pore-Purifying Pro-Infusion Serum🤩🤩 Book a @DiamondGlow treatment today in our office to experience clearer, blemish-free skin ✨
-
The DiamondGlow® device is a general dermabrasion device that gently removes the top layer of skin and delivers topical cosmetic SkinMedica® Pro-Infusion Serums onto the skin. This treatment is not for everyone. Some typical side effects include a scratchy sensation, tightness, and redness. Rare side effects may occur. Please talk to your provider for additional information.

💎Diamond Glow $125 (reg. $175) until April 30, 2024! 
*Only offered at our Northwest Hills office 

Call To Book To Schedule Today!
☎️Phone: (512)328-4100 ext. 2 Westlake Hills;
(512)640-8111 Northwest Hills
📆Book online: https://bit.ly/BookMedSpaAustin
📧Email: info@drjenniferwalden.com
🌎Website: TheMedSpaAustin.com 
🎟️Memberships: https://bit.ly/medspamember
🛍 Shop: https://shop.drjenniferwalden.com/
⭐️Join our VIP App: https://drwalden.repeatmd.com/
🍒 Apply For Cherry: https://pay.withcherry.com/the-medspa-at-westlake-hills-by-dr-jennifer-walden
💳 Finance Today with Patient Fi https://app.patientfi.com/v2/drjenniferwalden/enterprise

#DiamondGlow #RevealYourRadiance #DiamondTip #DiamondTechnology #ProInfusion #PoweredbySkinMedica #FacialTreatment #Glow #Facial #GlowySkin #SkinGoals #Skincare #BeautyTreatment #ProfessionalFacial #SkincareRoutine

Accessibility Toolbar

Scroll to Top